Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of hotels in Montauk, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| North Harbor Montauk Villa |
9.0 / 10 (55 Reviews) |
From 1379$ | |
| Townhouses & Captain'S Quarters Aparthotel |
8.6 / 10 (5 Reviews) |
From 415$ | |
| Montauk Lake House Villa |
10.0 / 10 (1 Reviews) |
From 1799$ |
It’s hard to pick just one reason to love Montauk, but if we had to narrow it down, Cottage would be one of the top reasons. From its charming small-town feel to its incredible natural beauty, Cottage has something for everyone.
Located on the easternmost tip of Long Island, Montauk is a popular summer destination for New Yorkers and visitors from all over the world. Famed for its stunning coastline, fishing villages, and miles of unspoiled beaches, Montauk is a nature lover’s paradise. But there’s more to this picturesque town than just natural beauty.
With its trendy restaurants and bars, lively nightlife, and fabulous shopping, Montauk is the perfect place to enjoy a fun-filled vacation. And when you need a break from the hustle and bustle of town, there’s plenty of outdoor recreation to be found, from hiking and biking to fishing and kayaking.
So if you’re looking for a relaxing, waterfront getaway, be sure to check out Cottage. We promise you won’t be disappointed.
Montauk Accommodation lists:
View all photos
North Harbor Montauk Villa
From 1379$
Offering a golf course, a patio and a sun deck as well as 7 rooms, North Harbor Montauk Villa is set 2.5 km from Theodore Roosevelt County Park. This venue is 2.1 km from Montauk Downs State Park.
The centre of Montauk is nearly 4 km from the accommodation. You will find a seafood restaurant serving American cuisine nearby. You can get to Gosman's Dock in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Townhouses & Captain'S Quarters Aparthotel
From 415$
The 111 m² The Captain'S Quarters Villa is situated in close proximity to Second House Museum. Comprising 3 bedrooms and a kitchen, the venue provides a tennis court and barbecue and is 15 minutes' walk from the city centre.
Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course is located 2.1 km from the accommodation and Kirk Park Beach is just about 0.7 km away. It is within a stroll from a beach. Guests will find the café Ralph's Italian Ices & Ice Cream within a 5-minute walk. The proximity to Sunset Surf Shack is a perk for those staying at The Captain'S Quarters Villa.
View all photos
Montauk Lake House Villa
From 1799$
This 4-bedroom Montauk Lake House can accommodate 6 people, measures 186 m² and provides guests with lake views. Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course is 5 minutes' drive and Shadmoor State Ocean Park can be reached with a 10-minute drive.
The centre of Montauk is nearly 5 km from the venue. You can get to Montauk Racquet Club in a few minutes by car.
Holiday Cottages in Montauk
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #3 - Std Queen
From 313$
The 1-bedroom Ruschmeyers # 3 - Std Queen is less than a 15-minute walk from Second House Museum. This accommodation includes air conditioning and high-speed internet.
Hither Woods Preserve Campgrounds is approximately 10 minutes' drive away. The centre of Montauk is a 10-minute walk away. You can get to Montauk Downs State Park in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #15 - Dlx Queen
From 563$
The venue offers accommodation in Montauk, 2.8 km from Montauk Downs State Park and 2.5 km from Hither Woods Preserve Park. Air conditioning and wireless internet are included in the rooms at Ruschmeyers # 15 - Dlx Queen.
The villa is located within 1 km of the city centre. You can get to Kirk Park Beach in a few minutes by car.
Hotels in Montauk
| Airport nearby ✈️ | Hartford-Brainard, Tweed-New Haven, Long Island MacArthur, T.F. Green |
| Average Price 💰 | 687$ |
| Hotels in Montauk 🏨 | 45 |
| Hotel Reviews ⭐ | 736 |
| Landmarks nearby 📍 | Hither Hills State Park, Montauk Lighthouse Museum, Camp Hero State Park, Shadmoor State Park, Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course |
| Hotel with balcony 🌤️ | North Harbor Montauk Villa |
| Hotel with a view 🔍 | Townhouses & Captain'S Quarters Aparthotel |
| Top Hotel for couples 💑 | Montauk Lake House Villa |
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #12 - Dlx Queen
From 519$
This property is located 2.8 km from Montauk Downs State Park and 2.5 km from Hither Woods Preserve Campgrounds. Air conditioning, wireless internet and multi-channel television are featured in the rooms at Ruschmeyers # 12 - Dlx Queen.
The venue is 10 minutes' walk from Montauk city centre. You can get to Second House Museum in a few minutes by car.
Holiday Cottages in Montauk with Private Pool
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #10 - Dlx Queen
From 430$
The 1-bedroom Ruschmeyers # 10 - Dlx Queen is less than a 15-minute walk from Second House Museum. This venue offers units with climate control and high-speed internet.
Hither Woods Preserve Campgrounds is approximately 10 minutes' drive away. The centre of Montauk can be reached within 1 km. You can get to Montauk Downs State Park in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #8 - Std Queen
From 314$
Set 2.8 km from Montauk Downs State Park and 1.4 km from Second House Museum, the venue is located in Montauk. Ruschmeyers # 8 - Std Queen features rooms with air conditioner and high-speed internet.
The property is located within 1 km of the city centre. You can get to Hither Woods Preserve Campgrounds in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #17 - Dlx King
From 431$
This venue is 10 minutes' drive from Montauk Downs State Park and 2.5 km from Hither Woods Preserve Park. Ruschmeyers # 17 - Dlx King offers rooms with air conditioner and wireless internet for a comfy stay.
The centre of Montauk is a 10-minute walk from the accommodation. You can get to Second House Museum in a few minutes by car.
Luxury Holiday Cottages in Montauk
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #7 - Std Queen
From 510$
Boasting the location 2.5 km from Hither Woods Preserve Park, the venue is also 2.8 km from Montauk Downs State Park. Ruschmeyers # 7 - Std Queen comprises rooms with air conditioner and Wi-Fi.
The centre of Montauk is nearly 1 km from the accommodation. You can get to Second House Museum in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #5 - Std Queen
From 510$
This venue offers accommodation in Montauk, 2.8 km from Montauk Downs State Park and 2.6 km from Montauk Racquet Club. Ruschmeyers # 5 - Std Queen offers rooms appointed with climate control and high-velocity internet for guests’ convenience.
The villa is located within 1 km of the city centre. You can get to Gosman's Dock in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #6 - Std Queen
From 941$
The 1-bedroom Ruschmeyers # 6 - Std Queen is less than a 15-minute walk from Second House Museum. This venue offers units with climate control and high-velocity internet.
Montauk Downs State Park is approximately 10 minutes' drive away. The centre of Montauk is less than 1 km away. You can get to Hither Woods Preserve Campgrounds in a few minutes by car.
Dog-Friendly Cottages in Montauk
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #2 - Std Queen
From 490$
Set 2.5 km from Hither Woods Preserve Park and 2.8 km from Montauk Downs State Park, the venue is located in Montauk. Ruschmeyers # 2 - Std Queen has rooms with climate control and high-velocity internet.
The property is located within 1 km of the city centre. You can get to Kirk Park Beach in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #19 - Dlx King
From 431$
The venue is located 2.5 km away from Hither Woods Preserve Campgrounds and about 1.4 km from Second House Museum. There are rooms with air conditioner and WiFi in Ruschmeyers # 19 - Dlx King.
The accommodation is 10 minutes' walk from the centre of Montauk. You can get to Montauk Downs State Park in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #4 - Std Queen
From 314$
Ruschmeyers # 4 - Std Queen is located 10 minutes' walk from Fort Pond Bay Park and 15 minutes' walk away from Second House Museum. This property offers units with climate control and wireless internet.
The centre of Montauk is nearly 1 km from the venue. You can get to Hither Woods Preserve Campgrounds in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #1 - Queen
From 314$
This venue offers accommodation 2.5 km from Hither Woods Preserve Park, while Montauk Downs State Park is 2.8 km away. Ruschmeyers # 1 - Queen comprises rooms with climate control and WiFi.
The centre of Montauk is nearly 1 km from the villa. You can get to Second House Museum in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #16 - 2 Queen
From 1698$
The 1-bedroom Ruschmeyers # 16 - 2 Queen is less than a 15-minute walk from Kirk Park Beach. Air conditioner and WiFi are available at this venue.
Hither Woods Preserve Park is approximately 10 minutes' drive away. The centre of Montauk is a 10-minute walk away. You can get to Montauk Downs State Park in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #11 - Dlx Queen
From 330$
The venue offers accommodation in Montauk, 2.5 km from Hither Woods Preserve Park and 2.8 km from Montauk Downs State Park. Air conditioner and wireless internet are available in all guest rooms at Ruschmeyers # 11 - Dlx Queen.
The villa is located within 1 km of the city centre. You can get to Second House Museum in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #9 - Dlx Queen
From 623$
This property is located 2.8 km from Montauk Downs State Park and 1.4 km from Second House Museum. Air conditioning and WiFi are a standard in Ruschmeyers # 9 - Dlx Queen.
The venue is 10 minutes' walk from Montauk city centre. You can get to Hither Woods Preserve Park in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #14 - Dlx Queen
From 330$
While staying at the venue, you'll be 2.5 km from Hither Woods Preserve Campgrounds and 2.8 km from Montauk Downs State Park. Climate control and wireless Internet are featured in these rooms of Ruschmeyers # 14 - Dlx Queen.
The villa is 10 minutes' walk from Montauk city centre. You can get to the large Ditch Plains Beach in a few minutes by car.
View all photos
Ruschmeyers #13 - Suite
From 1115$
The property is 2.5 km from Hither Woods Preserve Park and 10 minutes away by car from Shadmoor State Ocean Park. Ruschmeyers # 13 - Suite features rooms with air conditioner and high-speed internet.
The venue is 10 minutes' walk from Montauk city centre. You can get to Second House Museum in a few minutes by car.